Esoteric Resources Incorporated is pleased to present the text of this MTA New York City Transit Authority brochure which delineates the proposed cuts in service sought by the NYCTA.
We have tried to keep the brochure intact, with mild corrections to make the proposals intelligible. The order of presentation is complete, but we have changed the order of presentation to a logical format: either in order by bus route number (for buses), or geographically, within borough, north to south (for token booths). We have spelled out most abbreviations.
At the time of writing - April 7, 1995, 01:30 A.M. - there are allegations that these cuts have been incompletely presented to the public. Readers may note that no mention is made of service cuts in train service , such as fewer trains and/or longer headways. Esoteric Resources will present that information as soon as it becomes available.
Esoteric Resources Incorporated takes responsibility for any errors caused by converting this document into a Web Page. If you have any comments on that, feel free to e-mail us.
MTA New York City Transit is losing much of the government funding we count on to run daily subway and bus service. To balance our budget, we have to cut costs sharply. Unfortunately, cuts in some services can't be avoided. We have prepared this brochure to outline our proposals for these reductions.
Even though fares pay for about 60% of our operations, we rely on aid from the city, the state and Washington to make up the difference. All these governments are undergoing financial crises and are slashing their subsidies. As a result, we're facing a $113 million deficit in 1995 that may grow to $340 million in 1996.
Most of NYC Transit's cost savings will come from scaling down administration and improving productivity. While some savings will come from maintenance programs, it would be unwise to put off the regular upkeep and replacement of equipment, as we were forced to do during the funding cutbacks of the 1970s and early 1980s. What we can't avoid are service reductions.
Service Proposals
Every service we provide is
important to some customers, but some services are not used as heavily
as others. In determining where to propose service changes, we have made
every effort to be sensitive to the needs of our customers by focusing
on reducing services that are less frequently used. Therefore, we
believe that the following proposed service changes will minimize
inconvenience for the majority of our customers.
NYC Transit operates 203 local bus routes. During the late evening, overnight and on weekends, many bus routes are not heavily used. We propose to reduce the hours of operation of 28 of these local bus routes. We propose to discontinue three lightly used bus routes that have very low ridership and very high cost per customer. In addition, we propose to restructure six bus routes by combining duplicate service patterns, shortening routes or eliminating branches of routes where the demand for service is very low.
B2
Discontinue service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: B3, B31, B41/B44 buses; 2 train.
B5, B50
Combine bus routes to provide a consolidated east-west route between Bensonhurst and Starrett City.
Alternate service: All segments of both routes are covered by combined service.
B11
Discontinue service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: B6 bus for some customers.
B16
Discontinue service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: none.
B18
Discontinue service between 11 P.M.-12:45 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: B13, B60 buses; J, L trains.
B23
Discontinue service between 11 P.M.-1:30 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: B8, B9, B41, B68 buses.
B47, B62
Combine bus routes to provide a consolidated north-south route between Greenpoint and Prospect-Lefferts Gardens.
Alternate service: All segments of both routes are covered by combined service, proximate parallel service, or transfer connection.
B69
Discontinue service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: B48, B67 buses.
Bx3, Bx13
Discontinue combined Bx3 and Bx13 service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: Bx35, Bx36 buses.
Bx14
Discontinue bus service between 10:30 P.M.-12:00 Midnight every day.
Alternate service: none.
Bx17
Discontinue service between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: Bx15, Bx19, Bx55 buses.
Bx18
Discontinue Bx18 service.
Alternate service: Bx40, Bx42 buses for some customers.
Bx20
Discontinue weekday service between 4:50 A.M.-5:30 A.M. and between 11:30 P.M.-12:30 A.M.
Discontinue Saturday service between 5:50 A.M.-7:30 A.M. and between 11:00 P.M.-12:30 A.M.
Discontinue Sunday service.
Alternate service: Bx7, Bx10 buses.
Bx24
Discontinue Bx24 service
Alternate service: Bx7, Bx9, Bx10, Bx12, Bx20 buses.
Bx32
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service between 6:30 A.M.-7:00 A.M. and 11:00 P.M.-12:15 A.M.
Alternate service: Bx3, Bx9 buses.
Bx55
Shorten route on north end between 1 A.M.-5 A.M. every day. During the late night hours only, Bx55 service (which currently operates between 149th Street and Gun Hill Road) will terminate at Fordham Road.
Alternate service: none.
M116
Discontinue service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: M7, M102 buses.
M30
Discontinue weekday midday service between 10:00 A.M.-4:00 P.M. and all Saturday service.
Alternate service: M31, M72 buses.
M9
Discontinue service between 9:00 P.M.-10:30 P.M. on weekdays and weekends.
Alternate service: M14, M15, M21, M22, M101, M102 buses; N, R, 4, 5, 6 trains.
M35
Discontinue rush period only segment between Wards Island and Astoria.
Alternate service: M60 bus and transfer to M35 bus in Manhattan.
Q79
Discontinue Q79 service
Alternate service: none.
Q15
Discontinue service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: Q44 bus.
Q16
Discontinue service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: Q28, Q44 buses.
Q20
Discontinue weekday service between 9:00 P.M.-12:00 A.M.
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service.
Alternate service: Q14, Q44, Q65 (from College Point) buses.
Q26
Discontinue weekday service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M.
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service.
Alternate service: Q27, Q30 buses on weekends.
No alternate all night service.
Q42
Discontinue weekday service between 11:00 P.M.-1:00 A.M.
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service.
Alternate service: Q3, Q4, Q5, Q83, Q84, Q85 buses.
Q59
Discontinue service between 11:00 P.M.-1:30 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: Q58, Q54, B57 buses.
Q76
Discontinue service between 11:00 P.M.-1:30 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: none.
S55, S56
Discontinue service between 6:00 P.M.-10:30 P.M. Monday-Friday
Alternate service: none.
S57
Discontinue service between 11:00 P.M.-1:30 A.M. every day.
Alternate service: S54 bus for some customers.
S59
Discontinue service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M.
every day and
shorten service from Tottenville to Eltingville during
off-peak hours and on weekends.
Alternate service: Staten Island Railway, S78, S79, S44 buses.
S60
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service.
Alternate service: none.
S66
Discontinue weekday service between 1:00 A.M.-5:00 A.M.
Discontinue Saturday and Sunday service.
Alternate service: S40, S46, S48, S61, S62 buses.
Express bus routes operating from Brooklyn, Queens and Manhattan require NYC Transit to spend at least $9.00 per customer more than each fare brings in, much more than the $1.58-per-customer subsidy for local bus routes. Due to the high cost of operation, the relatively small number of daily customers and the availability of alternative rail service, we propose to discontinue all eleven express bus routes operating from these three boroughs.
X27
Discontinue service between Bay Ridge and midtown Manhattan
Alternate service: N, R trains.
X28
Discontinue service between Bensonhurst and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: B, N, R trains.
X29
Discontinue service between Coney Island and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: D, Q, F, B, N trains.
X90, X92
Discontinue service between the upper east side and lower Manhattan.
Alternate service: M15 Limited, M66, M30/M72, M79, M86 buses to 4, 5, 6 trains.
X25
Discontinue service between Grand Central Terminal and lower Manhattan.
Alternate service: M101 bus or 4, 5 trains.
X32
Discontinue service between Jamaica and The Bronx High School of Science.
Alternate service: Q17, Q26, Q27, Q28, Q44, Q88 buses to subway or Q44 to Bx22 bus.
X51
Discontinue service between Flushing and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: Q12, Q13 buses to 7 train, Q88 to R train, or LIRR.
X63
Discontinue service between Rosedale and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: Q5, Q85 buses to E, J/Z trains, or LIRR.
X64
Discontinue service between Cambria Heights and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: Q3, Q4, Q83 buses to E train, J/Z trains or Q4, Q83 to LIRR.
X68
Discontinue service between Floral Park, Bellrose, and midtown Manhattan.
Alternate service: Q43 bus to F train or LIRR.
NYC Transit operates three short subway shuttles. We propose to discontinue these services during late night hours, when they are used infrequently. Substitute bus service will be available for two of these routes and parallel subway and bus service is available for the other route.
3 Shuttle
Replace 3 shuttle service (between West 135th Street and West 148th Street) with shuttle bus service between 11:00 P.M.-6:00 A.M. daily.
Alternate service: M7, M102 buses; substitute shuttle bus.
Franklin Avenue Shuttle
Replace Franklin Avenue Shuttle service (between Prospect Park and Franklin Avenue) with shuttle bus service between 11:00 P.M.-6:00 A.M. daily.
Alternate service: substitute shuttle bus.
42nd Street Shuttle
Discontinue 42 St. Shuttle service from midnight to 6 am every day
Alternate service: M42, M104 buses, 7 train.
All subway stations have at least one token booth that is always open. Most subway stations operate additional "auxiliary" token booths and station entrances for customer convenience and to ease traffic flow during rush hours. Many of these auxiliary token booths and entrances arenot used frequently during the evening, overnight and on weekends. We propose to reduce the operating hours of 22 auxiliary token booths and entrances. In general, customers will have to walk only one or two blocks further to reach an open entrance.
We propose to permanently close the Dean Street station on the Franklin Avenue shuttle. NYC Transit remains committed to rebuilding the Franklin Avenue shuttle.
Dean Street (Franklin Avenue Shuttle S)
Close station at all times.
Nearest stations are Franklin Avenue A, C, S trains - 1160 feet away and Park Place S train - 1220 feet away.
Rockaway Avenue C
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth N123B (Manhattan-bound platform at Rockaway Avenue) from 6:00 A.M. - 9:00 P.M., daily to 6:00 A.M. - 10:00 A.M., weekdays only.
Alternate booth is located at Thomas Boyland Street - 770 feet away.
Kings Highway D Q
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth B024A (Quentin Road and East 16 Street) from 6:00 A.M. -12:00 Midnight, daily to 6:00 P.M. - 9:00 P.M., weekdays only.
Alternate booth is located at Kings Hwy - 240 ft. away.
Atlantic Avenue D Q 2 3 4 5 B M N R
Replace auxiliary token booth R616 (in the LIRR passageway) with turnstiles at base of LIRR platform stairs.
Operate turnstiles only during rush hours.
At other times, alternate booth is located at end of LIRR platforms - 340 feet away.
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth B002 (in the LIRR passageway) from 6:00 P.M. - 9:00 P.M., daily to 6:00 A.M. - 10:00 A.M., weekdays
Alternate booth is located at end of LIRR platforms - 340 feet away.
High Street A C
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth N101 (east side of Cadman Plaza) from full-time to 6:00 A.M. -12:00 Midnight, daily.
Alternate booth N101 is located at Cadman Plaza West - 2100 feet away.
Bedford Avenue - Nostrand Avenue G
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth N418 (at Bedford Avenue) from 6:00 A.M. - 9:00 P.M., weekdays to 6:30 A.M. - 9:30 A.M.
Alternate booth is located at Nostrand Avenue - 1100 feet away.
161st Street 4
Close auxiliary token booth R262 (elevated mezzanine) on weekends. Booth currently operates 6:00 A.M. - 9:00 P.M., daily.
Alternate booth is located in IND subway mezzanine - 310 feet away.
135th Street B C
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth N022 (downtown platform at 137th Street) from full-time to 7:00 A.M. - 9:00 A.M., daily.
Alternate booth is located at 135th Street - 530 feet away
42nd Street B D F Q 7
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth N502 (north side of 42nd St) from full-time to 7:00 A.M. - 9:00 A.M., weekdays.
Alternate booth is located on the southside of 42nd Street - 120 feet away.
42nd Street A C E
Close auxiliary token booth N060A (west side of 8th Avenue at 43rd Street). Booth currently operates from 6:00 P.M. to 6:00 A.M., daily.
Alternate booth is located at 44th Street - 260 feet away.
34th Street/Penn Station 1 2 3 9
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth R135 (in Penn Station at 32nd Street) from full-time to 6:00 P.M. - 9:00 P.M., weekdays.
Alternate booth is located in Penn Station, at 33rd Street - 250 feet away.
Close auxiliary token booth R137 (east side of 7th Avenue at 32nd Street) on weekends. Booth currently operates 6:00 A.M. - 9:00 P.M., daily.
Alternate booth is located at 33rd Street - 230 feet away.
Reduce hours at auxiliary token booth R139 (east side of 7th Avenue at 33rd Street) from full-time to 6:00 A.M.-12:00 Midnight, weekdays; and to 12:00 Noon-12:00 Midnight, weekends.
Alternate booth is located at 34th Street - 260 feet away.
59th Street/Lexington Avenue 4 5 6 N R
Close auxiliary token booth A004 (northwest corner of 60th Street and Lexington Avenue) and replace it with high exit turnstiles. Booth currently operates 6:00 A.M. - 9:00 P.M., weekdays.
Alternate booth is located across 60th Street - 60 feet away.
Park Place 2 3
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth R115 (Broadway and Park Place) from full-time to 6:00 A.M.-9:00 P.M. daily.
Nearest operating booth is located on Church Street - 520 feet away.
Grand Central 4 5 6 7 S
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth R237 (south side of 42nd Street at Park Avenue) from full-time to 6:00 A.M.-9:00 P.M., weekdays.
Alternate booth is located across 42nd Street in Grand Central Terminal - 300 feet away.
Cortlandt Street N R
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth A051 (downtown platform, in World Trade Center at Cortlandt Street) from 6:00 A.M.-7:30 P.M., weekdays to 4:00 P.M.-6:30 P.M.
Operate exit gates during A.M. rush.
Alternate booth is located one block away in World Trade Center - 230 feet away.
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth A053 (uptown platform at Cortlandt Street) from 6:00 A.M.-7:30 P.M., weekdays; to 4:00 P.M.-6:30 P.M.
Operate exit gates during A.M. rush.
Alternate booth is located at Dey Street - 230 feet away.
181st Street A
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth N007A (at 184th Street) from full-time to 6:00 A.M.-12:00 Midnight, weekdays and Saturdays; and to 9:00 A.M.-12:00 Midnight, Sundays.
Alternate booth is located at 181st Street - 910 feet away.
175th Street A
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth N011 (at 175th Street) from 6:00 A.M.-2:00 P.M. daily; to 6:00 A.M.-10:00 A.M., weekdays only.
Alternate booth is located at 177th Street - 600 feet away.
110th Street B C
Reduce hours of auxiliary token booth N034 (downtown platform, north side of 110th Street) from 6:00 A.M.-9:00 P.M., weekdays, to 6:00 A.M.-10:00 A.M.
Alternate booth is located at 109th Street - 400 feet away.
74th Street/Broadway 7
Reduce hours of auxiliary booth R525 (elevated mezzanine) on weekends only, from 6:00 A.M.-7:00 P.M. to 11:30 A.M.-7:00 P.M.
Alternate booth is located in the IND subway mezzanine - 400 feet away.
For more information on these service proposals, we invite you to attend public hearings at the times and locations listed below:
6:00 P.M., Thursday, April 27, 1995
The Roosevelt Hotel
Madison Avenue at 45th Street, Manhattan
6:00 P.M., Monday, May 1, 1995
Queens Borough Hall, Central Jury Room
120-55 Queens Boulevard
Kew Gardens, Queens
6:00 P.M., Tuesday, May 2, 1995
Brooklyn Borough Hall, Courtroom
209 Joralemon Street, Brooklyn
6:00 P.M., Wednesday, May 3, 1995
Bronx County Building, Veterans Memorial Hall
851 Grand Concourse, The Bronx
6:00 P.M., Thursday, May 4, 1995
New Dorp High School Auditorium
465 New Dorp Lane, Staten Island
At these meetings, you are invited to comment on any aspect of the proposals, providing that you register to speak. You may register until 9:00 P.M. at the hearing. Verbal presentations will be limited to three (3) minutes. The meetings will continue until all presentations are heard.
To register to speak, or for further information, contact:
MTA Government and Community Relations
347 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10017
Voice: (212) 878 - 7483
TTD: (212) 878 - 0165
All locations are accessible to the mobility-impaired. Interpreter services will be available for the hearing-impaired.
The horizontal line above marks the end of the printed matter in this NYCTA handout.
Esoteric Resources takes full responsibility for the content of these pages; if you have any comments, please mail us.
Page design is copyright 1995 Esoteric Resources Incorporated, NYC, NY, USA